By October, the southeast corner of Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway had been graded, and the desert beside the Walmart was gone. The town approved that grading in exchange for a protected stretch of Black Mountain. The 13-acre project, called Black Mountain Marketplace, rests on a trade. The developer is grading the entire commercial corner. The undisturbed desert the town requires is being set aside instead on hillside parcels that the developer or an affiliate already owned, under a conservation easement. The trade matters to anyone who drives that intersection, whether from Mirabel, Carefree or Cave Creek itself. Town staff describe this parcel as one of the last large pieces left along Carefree Highway, so the stretch is close to its finished shape.
A Corner Zoned Before the Town Existed
The corner has been zoned commercial for a long time. In its September 23, 2026 announcement, carried by City Sun Times, the Town of Cave Creek said the southeast corner was zoned commercial before the town incorporated in 1986. The same release calls the 13 acres General Commercial and says they are planned for a mix of retail stores and restaurants. The town expects the project to add significantly to its sales tax base.
The legal developer is Black Mountain Marketplace, LLC, which is named in the town's transfer-of-development-rights agreement in the May 19, 2026 Town Council agenda packet. That agreement is why this project is more than another shopping center.
How the Hillside Trade Worked
The commercial zoning had been in place for decades, but Cave Creek also requires 20 percent of a development site to stay undisturbed. The town and developer met that requirement through a transfer of development rights. The town has laid out the steps in its public records:
- Town staff approved the site plan with a condition. Before any building permits could be issued, either the Town Council had to approve a transfer-of-development-rights agreement or the project had to keep 20 percent of its own site undisturbed.
- The developer proposed grading the entire corner. It would provide 27 percent landscaped area there, above the minimum, and dedicate 98,298 square feet of required undisturbed area on two hillside parcels under a conservation easement.
- The staff report lays out the alternative. If the council denied the transfer, the developer would have to meet the 20 percent requirement on site, and the buildings might need to be reduced. Staff recommended approval of Resolution 2026-09.
- At the October 20, 2026 council meeting, Development Services staff named the town's legal tool, Resolution 2026-09, which lets commercial developers buy and preserve hillside acres, according to Citizen Portal's summary of that meeting.
The land under the new storefronts and the open hillside on Black Mountain were approved as one deal. The owner keeps fee title to the hillside parcels, and the easement restricts them to open space. In its release, the town says the trade protects "Cave Creek's unique landscape and view corridors." The release also covers water. The City of Phoenix will supply water for development south of Carefree Highway, so the project does not draw on Cave Creek's own water supply.
Where the Corner's Desert Went
The grading drew the strongest reaction, and the plants were moved on a set process. The town says the developer had a licensed professional prepare a Native Plant Inventory and a Salvage Plan. The salvaged plants go to a temporary on-site nursery, and the town inspects again once they have been moved there. During those inspections, extra trees and cacti turned out to be salvageable and were kept.
Development Services Director Luke Kautzman gave the council the totals on October 20. More than 160 native trees and 80 cacti have been salvaged for reuse in the project, as the Cave Creek / Carefree Independent reported.
Several council members still raised concerns. The Independent reported that council member Dusty Rhoades passed along residents' complaints about the land around the roadways being graded.
"The undisturbed around the roadways is what makes Cave Creek, Cave Creek."
Council member Tom Augherton shared concerns about how the landscaping would look. Kautzman said that once the work is finished, the landscaping should look much like the Walmart site next door did when it was completed. According to Citizen Portal, several council members and residents asked for a future ordinance change requiring an undisturbed roadside buffer of 15 to 20 feet. Black Mountain Marketplace was approved under the current rules, but this debate could shape how the corridor's few remaining parcels meet the road.
First Through the Door: A Gym and a Fuel Center
On October 20, Kautzman told the council that permits had come in for Mountainside Fitness and Fry's Fuel Center, the first occupants of the development. Staff also reported that site-plan review is complete.
Kautzman covered several other commercial projects nearby in the same update. Here is where each stood at that meeting:
| Project | Location | Status at the October 20, 2026 council update |
|---|---|---|
| Black Mountain Marketplace | Southeast corner, Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway | Site-plan review complete; permits in for Mountainside Fitness and Fry's Fuel Center |
| ALDI | North side of Carefree Highway between 50th and 51st Streets | Ready for permits to be issued |
| Multi-tenant commercial center | Behind the Starbucks, northeast corner of 53rd Street and Carefree Highway | Awaiting plan submittal |
| 114-room hotel | Near Schoolhouse Road | In engineering review over the Schoolhouse Road right-of-way |
| Havelina Springs Crossing | Cave Creek | Office/retail plans in review |
The ALDI parcel started a year earlier. A project narrative dated September 1, 2025 names SC Fullerton Properties, LLC as the developer. It asked for rezoning of the eastern parcels and site-plan approval for a retail and restaurant center, according to the town's planning exhibit. The proposed hotel near Schoolhouse Road would have two stories, a detached lobby, spa rooms and a pool. Engineers were still working out how it connects to Galloway on the north and the post office on the south.
The Last Big Pieces on Carefree Highway
Kautzman ended the update by putting the marketplace in context:
"The Black Mountain and the ALDI are the last real sizable parcels of land to be developed along Carefree Highway. We have like three or four parcels of two acres each left for development."
Compare the 13 acres at Black Mountain Marketplace with the three or four parcels of about two acres each that staff say are left. The marketplace is several times the size of any remaining lot. After it and the ALDI are built, Cave Creek's part of Carefree Highway will have no single parcel large enough for another project of this size. The Walmart corner is getting one more anchor block, and then the road is largely built out.
The trade fits into a larger open-space effort. In the same meeting, Kautzman said the town plans to bring the council a November update on its purchase of 4,005 acres of open space from the Arizona State Land Department. On one side of Carefree Highway, the commercial corner is filling in. Away from the road, acreage is being bought and protected.
Meanwhile, Back on the Fairways at Mirabel
Mirabel's own calendar has turned too. The Arizona Golf Association's 2026 overseed schedule listed the Mirabel course as closing on September 17, 2026, with reopening scheduled for October 20, 2026. That is the same day the Cave Creek council heard the Black Mountain Marketplace update. At the club, Cassandra Lematta joined this year as director of membership and marketing, coming from Jonathan Club, as BoardRoom reported in August. The club's events page lists cocktail parties, cooking lessons, golf tournaments, classes and crafting.
For the corner at Cave Creek Road and Carefree Highway, the town's own records show where things stand. The rest of Black Mountain Marketplace will be built on the same deal that preserved hillside acres on Black Mountain.
At Power+, we follow the projects reshaping the foothills from inside the community, from the Mirabel fairways to the Carefree Highway corridor. If you would like a resident's read on what this changes for your property, schedule a private consultation with our Desert Mountain experts.